Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Beanie Baby: $5,000

We certainly would’ve never guessed that a “Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Beanie Baby” would fetch up to $5,000. It’s certainly a steep price, but this expensive value is due to a manufacturing error. As a result, only 2,000 of these toys were made. You could say that this is one error that was dramatically done right in the long run.

As we said, these royal blue “Peanut” elephants are now worth at least $5,000. Today, it’s the most collectible and valuable Beanie Baby in existence. If you happen to own one, then you might be looking at a pretty sizable return on your investment. Another valuable version is the Humphrey the Camel which has a value of at least $2,000.